Mars - Curiosity Rover Discussion and Questions

Post Reply
User avatar
theENIGMATRON
Website Developer
Website Developer
Posts: 4326
Joined: Thu Mar 05, 2009 9:10 pm
PSN ID: theENIGMATRON
Steam ID: theenigmatron
Game of the Week: Barbie Beauty Boutique
Movie of the Week: Twilight Saga

Well by now you should know, and if you dont WAKE UP and read the news.

Anyway a couple of questions i keep seeing POP up around the net time after time, So i though i would open a thread and answer these questions and talk about them :-)

Q - How much Did Curiosity Rover Cost:
A - $2.5 Billion was the expect cost for the making of this machine, It was over ran and added another $1 to the final cost.
The Final Machine Cost £3.5 Billion

Q - We send a $3.5 Billion Machine to Mars, and we get a Black and White image back. But my Iphone can take better pictures, Are they stupid.....
A - No There not. Actually all we received back was a VERY LOW Res Image, They wanted something back quick, A test that all communications are working etc.

Q - Why request for a Low Res Image, when you can have a Colour HD Image?
A - The Distance between Mars and Earth is between 54.6 million to kilometers and 401 million km (Pending on the rotation)
Yet you cannot drive 50 Miles on earth without loosing your Signal to your Favorite Radio Station in the car....
Yet we have Masts and Dishes everywhere to bounce these signals around. So how is a Small Rover with a Dish the size of a Cup going to send Files back that quick.....

In simple it takes a WHILE to receive any data back, never mind images.
But there is more to it than that, There is only a Couple of Dishes on the Earth that are capable of sending and receiving information that far.
And there not freely available neither. Everyone uses these dishes, From people on Spacestations wanting to talk to family and friednds, to sending info and receiving info from multiple satalights.
They have to book a Time Slot in where they can use this Dish and send info and receive.

BUT WAIT, There is more, As where on two different Planets, that rotate at different Speeds and different Sizes, they have to book it in at a time when the Dish and Rover is pointing to one another.......
Or they have to relay the information of the Satalight that Orbits Mars adding a Further Delay to the whole process.

So in simple, Its not a Quick, Push a button, Lets get some info and control the robot.

The robot might move once a day for a hour if that.
Expect results to come in very slow.

As they say "Patience is a virtue"
Image
User avatar
YorkshirePud
Chief Trekkie
Chief Trekkie
Posts: 2400
Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2010 7:02 pm
PSN ID: yorkshirepud82
Location: Shipwrecked and comatose

i think its an amazing feat of engineering and human endevour, its a shame its not a human there but until that time its excellent news that it made it safely, i must admit i thought that skycrane was a proper wacky heath robinson thing but dammit it worked!

what bothers me is these people who moan saying omg all that money wasted fix the problems on earth first LOLZ its much simpler to send a robot to mars....
An explosion now and then is nice. Keeps the mind sharp,
User avatar
theENIGMATRON
Website Developer
Website Developer
Posts: 4326
Joined: Thu Mar 05, 2009 9:10 pm
PSN ID: theENIGMATRON
Steam ID: theenigmatron
Game of the Week: Barbie Beauty Boutique
Movie of the Week: Twilight Saga

YorkshirePud wrote:i think its an amazing feat of engineering and human endevour, its a shame its not a human there but until that time its excellent news that it made it safely, i must admit i thought that skycrane was a proper wacky heath robinson thing but dammit it worked!
haha tell me about it, i was very susceptible that the thing would of failed.

As from the moment it leaves Earth's Atmosphere, and points in the right direction, it was basically catapulted to Mars.
With little to no Control in direction, Solo winds or storms or a miss calculation by a fraction could of made it miss Mars by 100 and 1000 of miles.

Then of course the crane, a Wacky idea, but it worked, so i still need to eat my own Hat :p
But hats off to everyone, a well planned and thought out mission then went perfectly to plan.
Image
Killzone_Kid
God Like Gamer
Posts: 1538
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:05 pm
PSN ID: blanks
Contact:

Lol dave, the rover is massive it weighs almost a tonne. The antenna is bigger than human head unless of course you have seen human head the size of a cup.
BEEPLEFIELD 3 - it is all about locks, unlocks and small cocks!
User avatar
theENIGMATRON
Website Developer
Website Developer
Posts: 4326
Joined: Thu Mar 05, 2009 9:10 pm
PSN ID: theENIGMATRON
Steam ID: theenigmatron
Game of the Week: Barbie Beauty Boutique
Movie of the Week: Twilight Saga

Killzone_Kid wrote:Lol dave, the rover is massive it weighs almost a tonne. The antenna is bigger than human head unless of course you have seen human head the size of a cup.
Referring to the size of OUR antenna, Comparison.
Aware of how big it is, been watching the making of it for years.
Attachments
082310Curiosity.jpg
082310Curiosity.jpg (907.09 KiB) Viewed 913 times
Image
User avatar
InfiniteStates
God Like Gamer
Posts: 4832
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:31 pm
PSN ID: InfiniteStates

Looks like it was made out of Technics Lego lol
User avatar
DJ-Daz
Admin - Nothing Better To Do.
Posts: 8922
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 1:54 pm
PSN ID: DJ-Daz-
XBL ID: DJ Dazbo
Steam ID: DJ-Dazbo

looks more like meccano. At least that wont melt (as quickly) on entry.
Image
Killzone_Kid
God Like Gamer
Posts: 1538
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:05 pm
PSN ID: blanks
Contact:

Top speed 144 metres/hour LOL
BEEPLEFIELD 3 - it is all about locks, unlocks and small cocks!
User avatar
DJ-Daz
Admin - Nothing Better To Do.
Posts: 8922
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 1:54 pm
PSN ID: DJ-Daz-
XBL ID: DJ Dazbo
Steam ID: DJ-Dazbo

YorkshirePud wrote:i think its an amazing feat of engineering and human endevour, its a shame its not a human there but until that time its excellent news that it made it safely, i must admit i thought that skycrane was a proper wacky heath robinson thing but dammit it worked!

what bothers me is these people who moan saying omg all that money wasted fix the problems on earth first LOLZ its much simpler to send a robot to mars....
Considering D&D probably started 10+ years ago and no doubt it was also bought and paid for 5 years ago, there's little anyone could do to stop it.
Image
Post Reply
  • Information
  • Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 15 guests